Goodfellas Slings Proper New York City-Style Pizza On Baxter Avenue

Apr 27, 2022 at 1:08 pm
In proper New York City street corner pizzeria style, Goodfellas' slices are long and flexible, allowing the bearer to fold a slice lengthwise and eat it while walking along.
In proper New York City street corner pizzeria style, Goodfellas' slices are long and flexible, allowing the bearer to fold a slice lengthwise and eat it while walking along. Photos by Robin Garr

Let’s welcome Goodfellas Pizzeria to Louisville! The first local outlet of a small but quickly growing Lexington-based chain, this corner spot in the Baxter Apartments at Bardstown Road and Baxter Avenue joins sibling eateries in Indianapolis and the Cincinnati area. 

The pizza is good, the meatballs are impressive and the scene looks like a spot in New York City’s Little Italy. Well, a little bit, anyway.   

Titled after the 1990 Martin Scorsese gangster flick of the same name, Goodfellas’ tongue-in-cheek mob theme extends from specialty pizzas like The Don and The Vinny to its Wiseguy Lounge, which has soft leather sofas, as well as silhouettes of mobster figures in fedoras and the Italian-American crooners of the ‘50s and ‘60s.

As I walked south on Baxter toward the restaurant, which is tucked into the southern corner of the large, four-story apartment complex, I was impressed with its style. 

The street level, where Goodfellas is located, houses businesses — Carali’s Rotisserie Chicken and Hi-Wire Brewing are also in the building — built in a storefront style that fits in neatly with the adjacent stretch of Baxter. Good work! 

The interior gets that old-school Little Italy look from lots of exposed brick and arches, subway-tile backsplash, wood tables, an impressive bar and attractive white hexagonal-tile flooring with black accents. Oh, yeah, and a long, glass-fronted case to keep oversize pizza slices warm and ready, just like at your NYC street-corner slice shop.

Speaking of which, you can sample a slice for a very attractive price if you take advantage of Goodfellas’ lunch special:  A slice, a side and a soft drink for $8, or the Al Pacino meatball sub and a drink for $9. It’s an offer you can’t refuse, available seven days a week from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.  

If you prefer a whole pie — “hand-tossed, fresh-made, baked on the stone” — they come in 12-inch, 16-inch and 22-inch sizes for $11, $16 or $22 respectively, plus $2, $3 or $4 for each of the nearly 30 topping choices. Another deal worth noting: “Subject to some restrictions,” 12-inch pizzas are half-price on Mondays.

About a dozen specialty pies, most bearing faux mafioso names, come in three sizes and vary in price depending on the ingredients: The Fuhgetaboutit, adorned with every available topping, tops the charts at $20, $30 or $42. You can also choose a calzone for $9, plus topping surcharges.

click to enlarge Named after the actor Al Pacino, Goodfellas' singnature meatball sub bears a half-dozen hefty, well-made meatballs. Tony Corleone would have given it two thumbs up.
Named after the actor Al Pacino, Goodfellas' singnature meatball sub bears a half-dozen hefty, well-made meatballs. Tony Corleone would have given it two thumbs up.

The Pacino sub, when you’re not getting it as a lunch special, goes for $9. A half-dozen sides, many of them suitable as light meals, range in price from $3 (for an extra large breadstick) to $12 (for buffalo chicken cheese bread). Three salads are available for $3 each.

We took advantage of the lunch special and grabbed both a slice and a meatball sub. A slice adorned with strips of green pepper and purple onion caught my eye, and I didn’t have any complaints about its flavor either. In proper New York City style, these slices are long and flexible, making it easy to fold your slice and walk away.

Also in proper NYC style, the guy behind the counter took my slice and popped it back in the oven to warm up briefly before handing it over. The crust was thin and nicely browned from the hot oven, and the edge, lightly pocked with heat marks, was exceptionally chewy. 

The pie bore a slightly spicy and gently sweet layer of thick tomato sauce topped with abundant melted cheese and fresh, crisp-tender veggies. Not bad, although I can’t say it really reminded me of grabbing a slice for lunch in TriBeCa.  

I chose a caprese salad as my free side and got an uninspiring looking little black plastic box with a clear lid. Happily, looks were deceiving: It was very good. Neatly stacked in six parts were whole fresh basil leaves, hefty slices of bright-red roma tomato and thick half-moons of fior di latte mozzarella. It was all dusted with an Italian-style herb mix and drizzled with olive oil. 

The meatball sub special was an impressive value for $9. Its hoagie-type roll, billed as a Tribeca baguette, boasted a good crunchy crust. It was stuffed with six large meatballs, slathered with sweet, thick marinara sauce and mozzarella, then broiled. The walnut-size meatballs were light, easy to bite, made with a beef and pork blend that added complexity of flavor and texture. It was a splendid meatball, good as you’re likely to find in Gotham.

A filling lunch came to a thrifty $18.02, plus a $4.50 tip.

Goodfellas Pizzeria 642 Baxter Ave. 398-5704 goodfellaspizzeria.com/louisville

Keep Louisville interesting and support LEO Weekly by subscribing to our newsletter here. In return, you’ll receive news with an edge and the latest on where to eat, drink and hang out in Derby City. 

Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.