Fish Fry Season Is Upon Us: Where To Go In Louisville This Year

Easter is late this year, and working backwards, that means that Mardi Gras and Ash Wednesday are a little behind schedule, too. Fat Tuesday is coming up on March 1, and Ash Wednesday, beginning the penitential season of Lent, is March 2, one week from today.

In other words, if you’ve been craving fried fish a little more than usual lately, there may be a reason for that: In a more typical year, Lenten fish-fry season would already be well under way.

Lent, of course, is the 40-day-long liturgical season leading up to Easter, during which time many people undertake modest symbolic sacrifices such as eating fish rather than meat on Fridays. 

Lenten sacrifices are widely seen as a Catholic tradition, based on centuries when fasting practices including abstinence from meat was not just a suggestion but a requirement. But even after the Reformation, several mainline Protestant churches – Episcopalians, Lutherans, and Methodists in particular – continue observing Lent. including the option of taking on some form of abstinence as a spiritual practice.  

Of course, in Louisville we don’t wait until Lent to enjoy seafood and fish. Fried cod, scrod, and other mild white fish on rye bread or a bun is a local tradition that goes back to the 19th century, and it’s just about as typically Louisville as the Hot Brown, benedictine, or modjeskas. Go north and you’ll have a hard time finding fried fish in a sandwich. Head south, and your sandwich bears catfish.

Historians trace this local affection to a predominantly Catholic wave of immigration during much of the 1800s, a wave of migrants dominated by Germans but also filled with plenty of Irish and smaller Italian and Lebanese Catholic streams. They were required to eat fish on Fridays by church tradition, and local bars and restaurants quickly sprang up to serve them. 

Fed by speedy L&N express trains rushing seafood and fish from the Gulf in refrigerator cars full of ice, this inland town became a fish-loving city despite our distance from salt water. And if the fish got here just a bit past prime, frying it crisp and slathering it with tartar sauce or spicy cocktail sauce may have been more palatable than serving it delicately au naturel.

Of course, crunchy, sizzling, crunchy golden-brown fried fish is delicious and hardly penitential, and the same goes twice over for fancy fish dinners and seafood. Fish is healthful, too, high in protein and relatively low in calories. Even fatty fish like tuna and salmon are rich in the omega-3 fatty acids that – like red wine – seem to be beneficial to heart health.

So as time went by and the 20th century moved toward the 21st, fish on Fridays seemed less penitential than ever, and church rules gradually relaxed. But fish is popular all year ‘round, even when you’re not required to eat it. Many Roman Catholic churches offer community fried fish dinners on Fridays during Lent, beginning Friday, March 4 this year and continuing through the Friday before Holy Week, April 8.

For the last couple of years, the pandemic has forced some changes in practice. Some churches called off their fish fries for the duration, and others went to takeout or curbside service only. Only about two dozen of the Archdiocese of Louisville’s 100-plus parishes had Lenten fish fries last year; but that’s still a lot of crispy fried fish down the hatch.

This year the number is up to 33 throughout the Archdiocese, which covers the western half of Kentucky, including about 25 in Metro Louisville. Here’s a quick look at Catholic parish fish fries in the metro for 2022. For complete details, and to catch any late additions, check the archdiocesan website’s fish-fries listing here.

St. Aloysius, Pewee Valley 40056

St. Albert the Great, 1395 Girard Drive, 40222

Ascension, 4600 Lynnbrook Drive, 40220

St. Athanasius, 5915 Outer Loop, 40219

St. Augustine, 1310 W. Broadway, 40203

St. Bartholomew, 2042 Buechel Bank Road, 40218

St. Bernadette, 6500 Saint Bernadette Ave., Prospect, 40059

St. Edward, 9608 Sue Helen Drive, 40299

St. Elizabeth Ann Seton, 11501 Maple Way, 40229

St. Elizabeth of Hungary, 1020 East Burnett Ave., 40217

St. Francis of Assisi, 1960 Bardstown Road, 40205

St. Gabriel the Archangel, 5505 Bardstown Road, 40291

Good Shepherd, 3511 Rudd Avenue, 40212

Holy Family, 3938 Poplar Level Road, 40213

Holy Trinity, 501 Cherrywood Road, 40207

St. John Paul II, 3042 Hikes Lane, 40220

St. Lawrence, 1925 Lewiston Drive, 40216

St. Margaret Mary, 7813 Shelbyville Road, 40222

St. Michael, 3705 Stone Lakes Drive, 40299

Most Blessed Sacrament, 3509 Taylor Blvd., 40215

Our Mother of Sorrows, 747 Harrison Ave., 40217

St. Paul, 6901 Dixie Hwy., 40258

St. Rita, 8709 Preston Hwy., 40219

St. Stephen Martyr, 2931 Pindell Ave., 40217

St. Thomas More, 6105 S. Third St., 40214

Two of Louisville’s Episcopal churches also plan fish fries this year:

St. Mark’s Episcopal Church, 2822 Frankfort Ave.

St Luke’s Episcopal Church, 1206 Maple Lane, Anchorage

Finally, if you just can’t wait for Lent, Louisville is awash with fried-fish eateries. Here are a few of my favorites, just to get you started. Think I missed one? Yell me up on Twitter @RobinGarr.

The Fish House, 1310 Winter Ave.

The Fishery, 3624 Lexington Road

Hooked on Frankfort, 3200 Frankfort Ave.

Mike Linnig’s, 9308 Cane Run Road.

Moby Dick Seafood Restaurant, 4848 Shelbyville Road and other regional locations.

Sal’s Pizza & Sports Pub, 812 Lyndon Lane

Suburban Fish Fry, 3901 S. Third St.

Keep Louisville interesting and support LEO Weekly by subscribing to our newsletter here. In return, you’ll receive news with an edge and the latest on where to eat, drink and hang out in Derby City. 

Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

About the Author

Storyteller and seeker. Writer, editor, recovering metro journalist; playwright, poet, once a classical DJ. Hardcore food-and-drink geek, serious home cook. Seminary grad, part-time Episcopal preacher. Did I say eclectic? Deeply rooted Louisville native who’s lived in NYC, LA and the Bay Area; political junkie and unapologetic leftie. Covering the Louisville dining scene in print media since the 1980s, and doing it online since 1994.

All Articles by this Author >