January 12, 2011

Follow the money

Former animal services director received thousands in unemployment despite resigning amid controversy

Gilles Meloche, the former director of Louisville Metro Animal Services who resigned in 2009 amid allegations of animal torture, sexual harassment, misappropriation of animals, and inhumane conditions at the agency’s 3705 Manslick Road shelter, received more than $10,000 in unemployment insurance compensation from the city last year, according to records obtained by LEO Weekly.

The documentation, provided to LEO by Louisville Metro Human Services following a lengthy open records battle between the publication and the Jefferson County Attorney’s Office, reveals that Meloche received $10,790 in unemployment insurance for 26 weeks in 2010 — the last disbursement arriving as late as Nov. 17, 2010 — despite voluntarily resigning. Additionally, Meloche was awarded $10,081 of “vacation pay – termination” just days before stepping down as the city’s top dog catcher, documents show.

“I think it’s outrageous,” says Metro Councilman Kelly Downard, R-16, a longtime LMAS watchdog. “My understanding is he’s ineligible because he quit… wait, I take that back: If (former Mayor Jerry Abramson) decides you can get paid, then you get paid.”

Downard questions the logic behind Metro granting benefits to Meloche given the former director is named as a defendant (along with Interim Director Wayne Zelinsky) in two sexual harassment lawsuits, as well as the rapid deterioration at LMAS during Meloche’s tenure, which lasted from July 2005 to December 2009.

“My understanding is that they have turned down several people (at LMAS) for unemployment insurance,” Downard says. “The uneven distribution of benefits ought to make the public as upset as can be about it… When I hear that, I stop and think, what in the world is going on? Taxpayers ought to be outraged. That’s their money, and it’s just being given out like it’s somebody’s private dollars.”

After the Kentucky Office of Employment and Training first disqualified Meloche from receiving benefits on Jan. 1, 2010, documents show the ex-director filed an appeal on March 25. That appeal was successful in large part due to the efforts of Abramson, who, with Deputy Mayor William Summers, submitted an assessment of LMAS’ working conditions to the state unemployment referee, which arbitrates claim cases.

“An assessment of the (Manslick Road) facilities by claimant’s direct supervisor (Deputy Mayor William Summers) and Mayor Abramson concluded that the conditions were not conducive to claimant being able to properly perform his job duties,” the appeals referee wrote on Apr. 29, 2010. “The employer’s lack of actions rendered the work unsuitable and allowed claimant no reasonable alternative but to leave the employment… Therefore, it must be held (Meloche) voluntarily quit unsuitable work with good cause attributable to the employment and is not disqualified.”

An April 23 letter signed by Assistant County Attorney Mary Ann Watkins explicitly states, “Louisville Metro Government does not challenge Mr. Gilles Meloche being awarded unemployment benefits.” --According to Bill Patteson, county attorney spokesman, the decision to not challenge Meloche’s unemployment claim was made by the Mayor’s Office, possibly by former Mayor Jerry Abramson, who praised Meloche as a “change agent” on more than one occasion.

On March 24, 2010, Meloche wrote an appeal letter to the Division of Unemployment Insurance, stating, “The decision and assessment of the working conditions were done by my supervisor Bill Summers, the mayor Jerry Abramson [sic] and me,” Meloche wrote. “On a common decision we all agreed that it was in the best interest of all parties, the department and the government that I resigned. I was definitely and completely unable to perform the normal and needed activities to manage the department. It would have also been detrimental on the animals that need full consideration to stay healthy and be adopted.”

Abramson, who begins an “executive-in-residence” position at Bellarmine University this week teaching classes about civic leadership, could not be reached for comment for this story.

The ease with which Metro allowed Meloche to claim benefits sharply contrasts its handling of other city employees’ benefits, especially those who have criticized the embattled animal control agency.

Most notably is Metro Public Works employee and former LMAS kennel attendant Eric Garrett, who in April 2010 was suspended without pay for speaking out against mismanagement and waste within the department, and who was ordered to undergo a psychiatric evaluation to retain his job. Prior to that snafu, Garrett claims he was transferred to Public Works from LMAS in 2006 as a result of criticizing Meloche’s decision-making. After some legal wrangling, the state government slapped down Metro’s denial of Garrett’s benefits.

Additionally, Metro has denied benefits to former LMAS animal care manager Dawn Simpson, who resigned Aug. 21, 2009, after alleging sexual harassment by Meloche and retaliation by him and Zelinsky, then the agency’s second-in-command. Legal documents show that Simpson appealed and attended three unemployment hearings in a process spanning several months, and ultimately was awarded only a fraction of the benefits she had claimed.

“We went through multiple hearings where the county attorney … fought us tooth-and-nail on her unemployment. It’s unbelievable,” says Mikell Grafton Skinner, Simpson’s attorney. “Their basis was that she quit voluntarily. She wrote a very specific letter the day she walked out of there, and she said she could not last one more minute in that environment,” in effect echoing the very argument made by Meloche in his resignation and appeals letters. Skinner claims that a clerical error also contributed to Simpson’s claims not being properly processed, and that the county attorney’s office exploits unemployment insurance awards by playing favorites.

LEO Weekly obtained the aforementioned records after appealing a series of decisions made by the county attorney’s office, each of which denied access to Meloche’s unemployment disbursement. The Kentucky Attorney General’s Office issued an opinion on Dec. 22, 2010, ruling that Metro had incorrectly invoked exceptions to Kentucky open records law in an attempt to withhold evidence that Meloche had collected unemployment.

“Louisville Metro Government improperly relied on (exceptions to open records law) in denying (LEO Weekly’s) August 16, 2010 request,” Assistant Attorney General Amye L. Bensenhaver writes in a five-page ruling. “Metro thus stands in the same shoes as all other employing units insofar as it is not bound by the confidentiality provision found at KRS 341.190(3),” which deals with exceptions to confidential information.

Patteson defends Metro’s reading of open records law, calling it “an abundance of caution on behalf of our client.”

“In terms of any further detail on discussions we would’ve had with Metro government (to not challenge Meloche’s claims), that is under attorney-client privilege, and we would need to have the permission of Metro to be able to go into any further detail,” Patteson says. “If Meloche isn’t disqualified, then there’s not sufficient grounds to challenge (the decision).”

Attorney Jon Fleischaker, who represents the Kentucky Press Association, reviewed the attorney general’s ruling and said that Meloche’s wage information is clearly public, calling the county attorney’s interpretation of open records law “a knee-jerk reaction.”

“The most neutral explanation I can give you for what they did is they don’t want to give out records, so they look for any reason not to,” Fleischaker says. “I just can’t see how anybody can read this statute and come up with the idea that (this information is) confidential. What happens is, and it’s not just with them, it happens with a lot of public agencies, they get … nervous that somehow they’re going to violate someone’s rights. In this case, I don’t know how they could’ve thought that because all of the salary information about Meloche is open (for inspection).”

Fleischaker adds that he doesn’t think it’s an inadequacy of what Patteson called the “broadly worded” open records statute, but rather a failure of the county attorney’s office to properly do its job.

“The best explanation I can give you is an absurd sense of being scared about what Meloche might do if they gave out the information,” Fleischaker says. “That’s just foolishness.”

Follow the Money

By thinknaloud
Score another one for real journalism and valuable reporting to our community! You bet I’m so angry I could explode Mr. Downard. It’s yet one more assault on everything good and decent and there seems to be no end in sight. Just how rotten was and is Louisville Metro Government? And how far up the food chain in Frankfort does this cover up go? Maybe Abramson & Summers went to bat for Meloche on the charges filed against him with the Kentucky Board of Veterinary Examiners too. We desperately need investigative reporting like this because Abramson is running for state office and if there’s one thing I know, we don’t need more corruption in Frankfort. It absolutely boggles the mind to think what havoc Abramson could wreak if he somehow stepped up to the office of Governor, not that he couldn’t have a hay day as lieutenant governor. One of the first things he’ll probably do is hire Meloche for some position that will become hopelessly corrupted and dysfunctional just like MAS. Just how far will Abramson go to cover up and watch out for Meloche? Well, as we learned in a WLKY story about a lawsuit filed against both Meloche & Zelinsky by former MAS animal care manager Dawn Simpson, “According to the complaint, Meloche repeatedly told Simpson and other animal services workers about his tight relationship with the mayor in an effort to prevent any complaints, and on multiple occasions referred to that relationship being like ‘gay love’”. As Seinfield would say, “not that there’s anything wrong with that.” Regardless of what motivates Abramson to defend Meloche, what is wrong is covering up for a horrible, corrupt and inept nasty piece of work at the expense of homeless animals and pet loving people in our community. It’s wrong to defend a bad hire director while he ruins an agency and abuses helpless animals, good pet owners and caring employees. It’s wrong to use your clout to get unemployment insurance for somebody who screwed things up so bad it was disgusting and then support his twisted argument that he couldn’t work in that atmosphere. It’s doesn’t matter if you’re straight or gay. Right is right and wrong is wrong. You have ethics and character or you don’t. Abramson and Meloche don’t. Ditto for Zelinsky. So Mr. Meador, please, sir, can I have some more? What else don’t we know about Abramson, Meloche, Zelinsky & MAS that we should?

disturbed by the cover-up

By curtis morrison
I'm not as disturbed about the severance package, as I am about the cover-up. Why the hell is the Jefferson County Attorney O'Connell STILL showing so much "gay love" to Former Mayor Jerry Abramson anyway? Oh, and what the xxxx else is he hiding for him?

Payback's a Be-atch

By EdenSprings
I believe that the taxpayers are entitled to a refund on this waste of our dollars. To say that Metro didn't support Meloche is laughable. They continually increased his budget until it was triple what it had been when he first walked through the door. They literally threw money at the guy and--just like in his former two jobs--he augured himself into the ground with his own practices. Jerry personally protected the guy in spite of his criminal background, his two failed audits and perpetually revolting behavior towards people and animals. If Metro abandoned anyone, it was the parade of whistle blowers who were harassed out the door or summarily fired for daring to stand up Meloche's abuse of animals under their care. The Commonwealth should launch an investigation into this fraud and demand repayment of all their money from Meloche (who, by the way, isn't even living in Kentucky). When he complains that he can't repay it, just tell him to call his sister in Canada and have her take it out of his secret bank account that's in her name. It's where he stashed all the $$ he got from selling anabolic steroids in Canada and the only reason he never went to jail was they couldn't find the money he'd hidden. You're a disgusting one, Dr. Grinch.

More Bad Behavior

By EdenSprings
If you're shocked that the County Attorneys office tried to cover this information up like a you-know-what in a litter box, don't be. Rumor has it that Mike O'Connell commandeered a recent 2% wage increase that was supposed to go to his employees. Instead, he's put in a secret fund that he controls. The same rumor also states that he forces his employees to donate to and vote for candidates of HIS choosing, and that failing to do so is grounds for termination. This, folks, is the guy you just elected to protect you from criminal behavior and uphold the laws of the Commonwealth. Seriously, you all need to be better informed before you hit the polls. Read more LEO!

This is so crazy that he

By don44
This is so crazy that he received all of this unemployment payment. He needs to be prosecuted to max here. This is so wrong to do here. Fishing in Canada

that is a good article.

By daxiong22
that is a good article. video converter for Avchd mts, m2ts, mxf, ts video to avi, mpeg-2 conversion software free. ts converter | convert canon video e site afin d’éviter qu’il manque encore. avchd converter camcorder camra video transcode.

Indeed, I observed which

By teresa
Indeed, I observed which Legal professional Jon Fleischaker, who presents the particular Ky Press Relationship, evaluated the attorney general’s lording it over and declared Meloche’s income details are plainly open public, calling the local attorney’s meaning associated with open information legislations “a knee-jerk reaction.”

As restoration pushed

By cciting
As restoration pushed forward on a theater that had been dark since 1966. mapquest mapquest driving directions

The abilities of students

By Edwards
The abilities of students are refined in the system of education. The nature has given various skills to all human beings. The direction and guidance is given in the teachings of education. The students benefit a lot from best custom wrіtіng servіce revіews this process of learning.